Makalu vs Broad Peak
Makalu (8,485 m) is 434 m higher than Broad Peak (8,051 m).
Makalu
✕
|
Broad Peak
✕
| |
|---|---|---|
| Mountain | ||
| Elevation | 8,485 m 27,838 ft | 8,051 m 26,414 ft |
| Prominence | 2,378 m | 1,701 m |
| Isolation | 17 km | 9 km |
| Where | Bhojpur · Mahalangur Himal | Gilgit-Baltistan · Gasherbrum |
| Type | Mountain first ascent 1955 | Mountain first ascent 1957 |
| Climbing | ||
| Category | Expedition | Expedition |
| Ratings |
Technical 5/7
Effort 7/7 · Extreme
35–60 days on the mountain
Acclimatization included
Altitude Death zone
|
Technical 4/7
Effort 6/7 · Severe
34–52 days on the mountain
Acclimatization included
Altitude Death zone
|
| Normal route | Makalu La / northwest side (1955 French standard route) 9 routes | West Spur / West Face (normal route, 1957 line) 2 routes |
| Days on the mountain | 35–60 days Estimate | 34–52 days Estimate |
| Whole trip | –40 days | –45 days |
| Total gain | 3,662 m | 3,200 m |
| Summit day | 785 m up · 11–16 h from Camp 4 (7,700 m) | 851 m up · 12–15 h from Camp 3 (7,200 m) |
| Best season |
JFMAMJJASOND
|
JFMAMJJASOND
|
| Statistics | ||
| Climbers per year | 72* spring 2026 season | 16* July 2022 (one summit day) |
| Success rate | 21% 1950-2019 | – |
| Deaths (all time) | 51 7 February 2025 | 49* August 2026 |
| Recent deaths | 3* 2026 | 15* 2016-July 2026 |
| Death rate | 16.3 per 1,000 climbers | 52 per 1,000 summits* |
| Main dangers | Altitude high Technical difficulty high Weather high | Altitude high Avalanche high Physical endurance high |
| Character (research scores, 1–5) | ||
| Views | ||
| Iconic shape | ||
| History & culture | ||
| Solitude | ||
| Nature | ||
| Easy access | ||
| Cost tier | ||
| More | ||
| Lists | Eight-thousanders 10 highest peaks of China 10 highest peaks of Nepal 10 most prominent peaks of Nepal High points of Nepal's administrative zones | Eight-thousanders 10 highest peaks of China 10 highest peaks of Gilgit-Baltistan 10 highest peaks of Pakistan |
| Why climb | Makalu is a striking, isolated four-sided pyramid near Everest and the fifth-highest mountain on Earth. Its normal route is technical high up, so it attracts experienced climbers looking for a harder 8,000 m peak away from the Everest crowds. The approach through the Makalu-Barun valley is also remote and wild. | Broad Peak is an 8,000 m summit beside K2, reached up the Baltoro Glacier past some of the finest mountain scenery on earth. Its normal route is less technical than many eight-thousanders, but the long summit ridge past the fore-summit tests judgement. Its 1957 oxygen-free first ascent is a landmark of lightweight Himalayan climbing. |
* estimate (or sources disagree) — tap or hover the asterisk for what the source says.
More comparisons
Mount Everest vs Makalu K2 vs Makalu Kanchenjunga vs Makalu Nanga Parbat vs Makalu Dhaulagiri vs Makalu Makalu vs Manaslu Makalu vs Cho Oyu Mount Everest vs Broad Peak K2 vs Broad Peak Kanchenjunga vs Broad Peak Nanga Parbat vs Broad Peak Dhaulagiri vs Broad Peak Manaslu vs Broad Peak