Black Giant vs Mount McDuffie
Black Giant (4,063 m) is 12 m higher than Mount McDuffie (4,051 m); they stand 3 km apart, both in the Black Divide. Normal routes: Black Giant's West Slope from Black Giant Pass (class 1-2) and Mount McDuffie's Southeast ridge from the Helen Lake / Ladder Lake side (2).
Black Giant
✕
| Mount McDuffie ✕ | |
|---|---|---|
| Mountain | ||
| Elevation | 4,063 m 13,330 ft | 4,051 m 13,291 ft |
| Prominence | 332 m | 208 m |
| Isolation | 4 km | 3 km |
| Where | California · Black Divide | California · Black Divide |
| Type | Mountain first ascent 1905 | Mountain |
| Climbing | ||
| Category | Trekking | Trekking |
| Ratings |
Technical 2/7
Effort 2/7 · Moderate est.
Acclimatization recommended · ~3 nights
Altitude High
|
Technical 2/7
Acclimatization recommended · ~1 night
Altitude High
|
| Normal route | West Slope from Black Giant Pass (near Muir Pass) class 1-2 YDS class 4 routes | Southeast ridge from the Helen Lake / Ladder Lake side 2 YDS class 3 routes |
| Days on the mountain | – | – |
| Whole trip | – | – |
| Total gain | – | – |
| Summit day | 424 m up from Lake 11,939 (below Black Giant Pass) (3,639 m) | – |
| Best season |
JFMAMJJASOND
|
JFMAMJJASOND
|
| Statistics | ||
| Climbers per year | – | – |
| Success rate | – | – |
| Deaths (all time) | – | – |
| Recent deaths | – | – |
| Death rate | – | – |
| Main dangers | Remoteness high Weather medium Navigation low | Remoteness medium Navigation medium Exposure / falls medium |
| Character (research scores, 1–5) | ||
| Views | ||
| Iconic shape | ||
| History & culture | ||
| Solitude | ||
| Nature | ||
| Easy access | ||
| Cost tier | ||
| More | ||
| Lists | Sierra Peaks Section Peaks List | Sierra Peaks Section Peaks List |
| Why climb | Black Giant gives a big High Sierra panorama for little climbing effort: Evolution and Ionian basins, the Palisades and LeConte Canyon 4,000 feet straight below. It is the natural side trip for John Muir Trail hikers camped near Muir Pass. | McDuffie is the second-highest point on the dark Black Divide, rising steeply above Le Conte Canyon and the John Muir Trail. It suits a multi-day trip in real solitude, combined with neighbours such as Black Giant, Scylla and Charybdis. |
* estimate (or sources disagree) — tap or hover the asterisk for what the source says.
More comparisons
Mount Whitney vs Black Giant Mount Tom vs Black Giant Mount Whitney vs Mount McDuffie Mount Tom vs Mount McDuffie